IFS Cloud · Shipment · Packing Proposal
Let IFS Cloud choose the box: how the Packing Proposal fills handling units
The Packing Proposal in IFS Cloud attaches the reserved shipment lines of a shipment to a near-optimal number of handling units of a suitable size. It works only as well as the volume and weight data on your parts and handling unit types, and this article shows what to set up and where it stops.
Key takeaways
- The Packing Proposal packs several shipment lines into several handling units, while the other automatic packing methods in IFS Cloud pack one shipment line per shipment handling unit.
- Parts and handling unit types without volume or weight are left out of the calculation, so master data decides the result before any rule does.
- The rules live on the Packing Proposal for Shipment Lines page: handling unit types, Max Volume Utilization (%), packing methods, Allow Mix Source Object and sort priorities.
- The proposal is set per Shipment Type, fetched as the default on new shipments and can run as an optional event at RESERVATION, CREATE PICK LIST or PRINT PICK LIST.
- It builds one level of shipment handling units only, and it does not handle Catch UoM parts.
When packers choose cartons and pallets at the dock, the number of packages and the freight weight on a shipment depend on who is on shift. The Packing Proposal replaces that choice with a rule you configure once and can check on every shipment. The packing itself still happens on the floor; what changes is that the shipment handling unit structure exists in IFS Cloud before picking starts, and the picker packs to it.
1.What does the Packing Proposal do in IFS Cloud?
The Packing Proposal is a set of packing rules that IFS Cloud applies to the reserved, not yet picked quantities of a shipment to create shipment handling units and attach the lines to them. It compares part volume, weight and dimensions with the capacity of the handling unit types you allow, and it aims either at high utilization of each unit or at short travel for the picker.
The difference to the other automatic packing methods is the number of lines per unit: they can pack only one shipment line per shipment handling unit, while the Packing Proposal looks at all reserved lines together. If pick lists already exist, it optimizes per pick list; otherwise it works on the full shipment. The reference page is About Packing Proposal on docs.ifs.com (25R2).
2.How the algorithm decides
The algorithm starts small and scales up, and it repeats until no unpacked quantity is left. The documented sequence is:
- Try the smallest unit. It tries to pack all remaining unpacked quantities into the smallest handling unit type that can hold them.
- Pack partially when nothing fits. If the quantities do not fit even into the biggest handling unit type, it adds a unit of the biggest type and packs part of the quantity into it.
- Sort the quantities. The order follows your sort priorities, typically descending Reservation Line Volume for utilization or ascending Route Order for shorter picking routes.
- Apply the packing method. It packs by source object, by reservation line or by piece, depending on which methods you enabled.
- Repeat. The steps run again on whatever quantity is still unpacked.
3.Setting up the basic data
All rules of a Packing Proposal are maintained on the Packing Proposal for Shipment Lines page, described in Add or Modify Packing Proposals. I set them up in this order, because each step depends on the one before.
Handling unit types
You list the handling unit types the proposal may use, and they must already exist. A handling unit type without volume or weight is not used. A type without dimensions is still used, but the dimension check for parts is then skipped, so a long part can be proposed into a carton it does not physically fit.
Max Volume Utilization (%)
This value caps how much of each unit's volume the proposal may fill, and IFS Cloud uses it to calculate Operative Volume Utilization. Filling 100% is not realistic once filler material and irregular shapes are involved. A setting of 80-85% is a practical starting point, which you then adjust against what your packers report.
Packing methods and Allow Mix Source Object
The packing method decides what the proposal keeps together. Allow Mix Source Object is available only when By Source Object is enabled.
| Setting | What it does | When I use it |
|---|---|---|
| By Source Object | Packs per source object, for example per order | The customer requires one order per package |
| By Reservation Line | Keeps the quantity of one line together | Receivers book goods in by line |
| By Piece | Packs piece by piece for box utilization | Freight cost matters more than package content |
| Allow Mix Source Object: Never | One source object per handling unit | Strict separation by order |
| Allow Mix Source Object: Always | Packs one source object at a time and may mix when it continues with the next | Many small orders to one consignee |
| Allow Mix Source Object: Small Source Objects | Source objects smaller than the biggest handling unit type can share one unit, but are not spread over several | Mixed order sizes on the same shipment |
Sort priorities
At least one sort order is required. Sorting by Reservation Line Volume packs most efficiently. If you sort by Route Order to reduce travel while picking, set Reservation Line Volume as Priority 2, otherwise utilization suffers.
Exclusions
Exclude Fully Reserved Handling Units leaves out shipment lines that reserve all material in an inventory handling unit, because such a unit is picked and moved to the shipment location as it is. On the Inventory Part page, the Exclude from Shipment Packing Proposal option removes a part's lines from the proposal; those lines are attached to shipment handling units manually.
4.When the proposal runs on a shipment
A Packing Proposal is connected to a Shipment Type and is then fetched as the default value for new shipments; the value can be changed on the Shipment page. Two conditions must hold before it can run: the Packing Proposal ID is connected to the shipment, and the shipment has reserved quantity that is neither picked nor packed.
- Automatically - add Pack according to Packing Proposal as an optional event on the Shipment Type, for RESERVATION, CREATE PICK LIST or PRINT PICK LIST.
- Manually - run Pack according to Packing Proposal for one or more shipments, depending on where you start it from, as described in Pack according to Packing Proposal.
- Corrections - the shipment handling unit structure can still be changed manually before picking.
The event you choose is a design decision. At RESERVATION, the structure exists early and can be reviewed; at CREATE PICK LIST or PRINT PICK LIST, pick lists exist and the proposal is optimized per pick list. How picking itself is organized is covered in IFS Cloud Picking: One-Step and Two-Step Picking Setup.
5.Reporting picking against the proposal
Picking is reported per shipment handling unit, either on the Report Picking of Pick List Lines page (Shipment Handling Units tab) or with the Report Picking of Shipment Handling Units data collection process. One setting on the Shipment Type decides whether the proposal survives partial picking: Keep Remaining Reservation at Partial Picking. Without it, a reservation attached to several shipment handling units is unattached and unreserved at partial picking, and the proposal you just built falls apart on the floor.
Stock that was picked but never left the site is a separate problem, described in Stock Picked but Never Shipped in IFS Cloud.
6.Limitations and implementation pitfalls
| Limitation | Effect on the shipment |
|---|---|
| Missing volume or weight | The part or handling unit type is excluded from the calculation |
| Serial tracking at Receipt and Issue | These parts are not handled by the proposal |
| Catch UoM parts | Not handled |
| One level only | No cartons inside pallets in one run; the proposal generates one level of shipment handling units |
| Package parts | Never packed directly; component reservations are included only when Pack Components in Shipment is enabled |
A part without volume or weight drops out before any rule is evaluated, so the first test run shows master data gaps rather than rule errors. Before go-live I run a query for inventory parts used on shipments that have no volume or weight, and I fill them or set Exclude from Shipment Packing Proposal deliberately. The second check is the sort order: Route Order without Reservation Line Volume as Priority 2 packs less efficiently than the documented recommendation.
The handling unit structure also feeds what comes after packing. When shipments are combined for one truck, the rules in Consolidated Shipments in IFS Cloud apply. When the forwarder booking is sent from IFS Cloud, the IFS Cloud to ROHLIG SUUS Logistics interface checks weights and dimensions against the carrier's requirements before sending and stops incomplete bookings at source, which is where complete handling unit data pays off a second time. Moving stock between your own sites uses a different object, the IFS Cloud Shipment Order.
7.Frequently asked questions
Can I run the IFS Cloud Packing Proposal manually on a shipment?
Yes. Pack according to Packing Proposal in IFS Cloud can be run for one or more shipments, depending on where you start it from. It can also run automatically as an optional event on the Shipment Type for RESERVATION, CREATE PICK LIST or PRINT PICK LIST. In both cases the shipment needs a connected Packing Proposal ID and reserved quantity that is not yet picked or packed.
Why does the IFS Cloud Packing Proposal skip some shipment lines?
The IFS Cloud Packing Proposal skips parts without volume or weight, parts with Exclude from Shipment Packing Proposal enabled on the Inventory Part page, Catch UoM parts and parts serial tracked at Receipt and Issue. With Exclude Fully Reserved Handling Units enabled, it also skips lines that reserve a whole inventory handling unit. Skipped lines are attached to shipment handling units manually.
Should the Packing Proposal sort by Route Order or by Reservation Line Volume?
Sorting by Reservation Line Volume gives the most efficient packing in the IFS Cloud Packing Proposal. Sorting by Route Order suits pick-to-box work, where the picker packs along the warehouse path, and in that case Reservation Line Volume should be set as Priority 2 so that utilization does not drop.
Can the IFS Cloud Packing Proposal put cartons on pallets?
No. The IFS Cloud Packing Proposal generates one level of shipment handling units only, so it proposes cartons or pallets but not cartons inside pallets in one run. A nested structure is built manually on the shipment, which is possible before picking.
What happens to the proposal when picking is reported partially?
When picking is reported per shipment handling unit in IFS Cloud, a reservation attached to several shipment handling units is unattached and unreserved at partial picking unless Keep Remaining Reservation at Partial Picking is enabled on the Shipment Type. Enabling that option keeps the remaining reservation and the proposed structure in place.
8.About the author
Dariusz Myśliwiec: 18 years hands-on with IFS (Apps 7.5 to 10 and IFS Cloud). IFS Certified Associate Consultant. PRINCE2® 7. Independent practice based in Kraków, delivered remotely across Europe and globally. You talk to the consultant who does the work, not a sales layer.
Selected clients from my IFS work: Fugro · LGC · BVI Medical · Betafence (PRÆSIDIAD) · Barlinek · NGK Ceramics · Newag · Oleofarm.
IFS is a registered trademark of IFS AB; this practice is not affiliated with IFS AB.
Send packed shipments to the forwarder straight from IFS Cloud
The ROHLIG SUUS interface runs on IFS Workflow with no middleware. It sends shipment details when the shipment is released, checks weights and dimensions against the carrier's requirements first, and links the booking reference back to the shipment.
See the ROHLIG SUUS interface Read: Consolidated Shipments in IFS Cloud